When John Fails the First Attempt - RDR1 Random Encounter Disasters

John Marston doesn’t always nail it on the first try… and this short compilation proves it. From botched wagon rescues to failed hanging interventions, chaotic bandit ambushes, unexpected standoffs, and even one execution gone horribly wrong - these are the moments where things did not go according to plan. This video is the second part of a 3-video series showcasing every Random Encounter I recorded while replaying Red Dead Redemption as both John and Jack Marston. Where Video 1 highlights every successful encounter, this one focuses purely on the first-attempt fails - the messy and unpredictable moments that make RDR1’s world feel alive. No commentary. Just pure, unfiltered chaos from one of Rockstar’s best games. Up Next: Video 3 – How Jack Handles Random Encounters - After RDR1’s Ending