Starting J.J. McCarthy a BAD IDEA? + Yankees Concerns | The Michael Kay Show - 10/22/26

Is starting J.J. McCarthy the right move for the New York Giants? On The Michael Kay Show, Michael Kay and the crew debate the Giants' decision to start McCarthy against the Houston Texans and whether New York can compete for the NFC East title. NFL analyst Chris Simms joins the show to break down the Giants' quarterback situation, explaining why he believes the team could have waited another week before starting McCarthy against a tough Texans defense. Plus, the conversation shifts to the New York Yankees as Michael Kay reacts to Aaron Boone's comments about competing with better teams in the MLB playoffs. Fans weigh in on Brian Cashman, the Yankees' offensive philosophy, batting average, and the organization's direction. Your home for all things New York sports — bringing you the energy, opinions, and insights that define the city’s sports scene. Weekday Lineup: DiPietro & Rothenberg — 6a-10a Carlin — 10a-1p The Michael Kay Show — 1p-3p Don, Hahn, & Rosenberg — 3p-7p https://urgentcarekit.com/880 Order today and save $45 when you use promo code 880. Chapters: 0:00:00 – Is Starting J.J. McCarthy a Bad Idea for the Giants? 0:30:00 – Aaron Boone's Concerning Yankees Comments 0:45:00 – Yankees Fans Frustrated with Brian Cashman & Offensive Struggles 1:00:00 – Chris Simms Joins the Show: J.J. McCarthy vs. Texans 1:30:00 – Michael Kay Debates Fans Saying "We" 1:45:00 – Yankees Fans Want Change & More Players Like Brett Gardner #ESPN #ESPNNewYork #NYsports #DiPietroAndRothenberg #Carlin #TheMichaelKayShow #donhahnrosenberg