16 Trading Gurus, 13 Referral Codes: Ek Hi Game?

Umar Punjabi said "I can make 36% return per month" (20 Sep 2026). Top G said his A+ setup wins "70%" (29 Sep 2026). We coded both strategies from their own words, ran every minute of 11 years of data (Nasdaq for Umar, gold for Top G) with real costs, and read the terminal: 44.3% and 14.5%. Then we opened the descriptions: the referral links, the $200 VIP gate on one broker, the "funded" accounts that are simulated, and 16 gurus' descriptions side by side. Every clip is dated; every page is archived; the code and every trade are on the proof page. Chapters 00:00 Dubai. Ferrari. 36%… (cold open) 00:38 Ek interview, chaar number (Umar Punjabi) 01:49 Humne strategy chalayi: data, code, live run 04:10 70% vs 14.5% (Top G) 05:57 Paisa kahan se aata hai? (IB, B-book, VIP, FortressFX) 07:35 Funded = simulated 08:54 16 gurus, ek hi machine 10:16 Hamari videos ka kya hua 10:47 Comment court 12:03 Fair note, verdict, mic drop Every trade, every screenshot, the rules, the code and the method: Umar Punjabi (Nasdaq "initial balance"): https://realshyt.com/proof/umar-punja... Top G / Atul Patil (A+ levels, gold): https://realshyt.com/proof/atul-patil... How we test any strategy (free guide): https://realshyt.com/guides/backtest-... Their videos quoted (short excerpts, for criticism and review): • Umar Punjabi on Morning Star Rohit, 20 Sep 2026 —    • Umar Punjabi ADMITS He Lied About 25% Mont...   • Umar Punjabi, "Prop Firm vs Broker", 5 Oct 2026 —    • Prop Firm vs Broker — What is Best for Beg...   (6:08) • Umar Punjabi on Figuring Out FO414 (27 Sep 2025; re-upload) —    • Delete podcast Raj shamani x Umar punjabi ...   • Top G Traders livestreams: 29 Sep, 8 Oct, 12 Oct, 13 Oct 2026 and others (video IDs and times on screen) Documents shown (all archived; dates = retrieval or publication): • Umar Punjabi's Notion "Payout Directory" (linked from his X), archived 14 Oct 2026 • Exness Affiliates, IB terms ("Up to 40% of revenue… Lifetime payouts"), 15 Oct 2026 • FCA CP16/40 (Dec 2016), paragraphs 3.18 and 3.42 — fca.org.uk/publication/consultation/cp16-40.pdf • ESMA, 27 Mar 2018 ("74-89% of retail accounts typically lose money"); XM risk footer ("75.12%"), archived 8 Oct 2026 • FortressFX: risk disclaimer, "Restricted Jurisdictions" help article, FAQ, terms §10, account specification (Pro, $200); archived 14–15 Oct 2026 • VIP descriptions: Umar Punjabi (W40QA2fTBOY, 1 Jul 2026); Top G (QJcYpwkyKjA + Google Form); Top G "BROKER I USE" (6 Sep 2026) • Legion Funding help centre, "Am I trading real money?" (8 Jul 2026); FSMA (Belgium) warning, 7 Mar 2024 • FundedFirm homepage, Internet Archive 14 Aug 2024 and 14 Dec 2024 • CFTC v. Traders Global Group ("My Forex Funds"), complaint 29 Aug 2023, ¶72 (allegations only). Dismissed with prejudice 13 May 2025, sanctions against the CFTC approved (Finance Magnates, 14 May 2025). Never tested in court. • Prop-firm closures 2024: Finance Magnates (15 Feb, 28 Nov 2024), TradeInformer (13 May 2024) • Morning Star Rohit, description of eQcs0EjzcWU ("Use Code MSR… affiliate links") • YouTube descriptions read 14 Oct 2026: Booming Bulls (fYXcAWFxyg0), Traders Paradise Live (Qv8r22pr9fA), TopG Hary (3qVXq9X5Y6g), Swappy Trading (M4G6BC6YHRM) and 12 more; Slay4X footer (archived) • RBI Alert List (19 Nov 2025), rows 6 Exness, 33 XM, 40 Vantage, 83 FundedNext (FundedNext says its listing was an error) • FSRA Saint Lucia, Warning Notice of 8 Jan 2026 — fsrastlucia.org/images/20260108_Updated_WARNING_NOTICES.pdf • SEBI interim orders: Baap of Chart (25 Oct 2023), Asmita Patel (6 Feb 2025), Avadhut Sathe (4 Dec 2025) • Our Instagram Rights Manager alerts (13 Oct 2026) and dispute outcome (14 Oct 2026); Delhi High Court Rights Manager suits (Bar & Bench 16 Jul 2026, TorrentFreak 27 Jul 2026). We accuse nobody. Data: Dukascopy historical datafeed (USATECHIDXUSD and XAUUSD, 1-minute BID/ASK, Jan 2015–Sep 2026); second source HistData. Costs: real bid/ask spread + the slippage and commission in the rules files. Code: Python; the excerpts on screen are real, and tests prove every trade matches the published results. Method on the proof pages. Our test, our opinion. Analysis of public claims, not advice: nothing here is a recommendation to trade, open an account or buy anything. Historical tests depend on rules, data and costs and do not guarantee future results. Not financial advice. Human research and editorial decisions by realshyt. The masked character is a fictional 3D host; production uses AI-assisted tools. Short third-party excerpts are used for commentary and criticism. Backdrop: "Dubai skyline" by Robert Bock (CC0) and "Ferrari 488 GTB" by Alexander-93 (CC BY-SA 4.0), via Wikimedia Commons; composite by realshyt. Music: original score made for realshyt with ElevenLabs. Next guru? Vote in the pinned comment. Instagram:   / realshyt__   #proofrun #backtesting #forex