Cop's ONE Texted Photo Puts a Man on Trial — Both Felony Charges COLLAPSE
Judge Harlan
0:00 / 0:00
Cop's ONE Texted Photo Puts a Man on Trial — Both Felony Charges COLLAPSE
925 просмотров · 4 дн. назад
Judge Harlan
439 подписчиков
925 просмотров · 4 дн. назад
A Colorado Springs officer saw a driver's face for a couple of seconds. About two weeks later his partner sent one photograph to his phone. He said 95%. With that identification at the heart of the case, a man named Clint Tabb was tried for two felonies.
Under oath, the detective explained why there was no lineup: "We treat each other as trained observers." Then the defense handed her the department's own five-page rule. Her partner, 26 years on the force, had already told the jury the same safeguards apply to police witnesses. The judge called the single photo "impermissibly suggestive" and let the jury decide. One charge was thrown out by the judge. On the other, the jury said not guilty.
This file adds what the courtroom video alone can't show: the actual General Order, the Colorado statute behind it, and what the research says about police officers as eyewitnesses.
CHAPTERS
0:00 "We treat each other as trained observers"
1:58 The glance: a couple of seconds through a windshield
4:45 Where the name came from, and the one photo
8:40 The rulebook: General Order 1036
10:19 "Police officers are people, correct?"
12:11 The "day after" that was two weeks
15:09 What the research says about police eyewitnesses
16:12 Her partner, 26 years on the job, answers differently
20:25 How did this get in front of a jury?
23:19 Count two collapses
24:38 The jury instruction the judge refused
26:05 Closing arguments
28:24 The verdict
28:57 My vote, and yours
Three choices: the detective, the veteran, the prosecutors. Who carries the most blame for putting Clint Tabb in that chair? One name in the comments.
I'm Judge Harlan. I don't judge the headline. I judge the record.
DISCLAIMER
This channel is commentary and education on public court proceedings and public records. The narration is an AI-generated voice and is disclosed as altered or synthetic content. Nothing here is legal advice. Mr. Tabb was found not guilty. Everyone shown is presumed to have acted lawfully unless a court or agency found otherwise; the findings described are quoted from the record.
FAIR USE
The original recording has been edited and combined with commentary, documents and legal analysis for educational purposes. This video is not a substitute for the original recording, which is linked above.
#courtroom #policeaccountability #eyewitness