Andy Gasper Murder: Cheryl Gasper's Plot and Randall Knight's 16-Year Confession

A red pickup behind a quiet New York plaza. A father found stabbed, seatbelt still on. What happened in Yorkshire in 1994 that no one saw coming? This episode of FBI Criminal Pursuit follows the cold-case hunt for answers after Air Force veteran Andy Gasper is killed in his truck and the keys vanish with his attacker. Detectives find no weapon, no witnesses, and no forensics—only a trail of letters, a shocking late-night phone call, and a love triangle no one wanted to admit. When a suspect is tried and acquitted, the file goes to the basement for 15 years—until the FBI’s Brent Isaacson and Rob Webb reopen it and play a careful game of chess with the two people who know the truth. A near-confession on paper, a haunting phrase from a phone call, and a motive buried in a life insurance policy push the case to a breaking point. How did investigators finally get not one, but two confessions? Watch to see how patience, psychology, and persistence cracked a murder-for-hire across state lines. #FBI #TrueCrime #ColdCase #MurderForHire #LoveTriangle #Confession #Documentary