Brilliant Directories AI Test: BD Butler vs ChatGPT vs Claude

🚀 BD Butler vs ChatGPT vs Claude – Which AI Builds the Best Brilliant Directories Pricing Page? In this Brilliant Directories tutorial, I put BD Butler, ChatGPT and Claude head-to-head to see which AI can create the best professional pricing page from the same basic prompt. Each AI is given the same instructions: • Create a professional pricing page • Use three side-by-side pricing tiers • Add suitable directory membership features • Highlight the most popular plan • Include a pricing comparison table • Make the comparison table usable on smaller screens • Optimise the content for SEO • Make the design responsive across desktop, tablet and mobile The three membership tiers are priced at £7, £14 and £21. Rather than giving each AI a highly detailed design prompt, I deliberately keep the instructions simple. This helps demonstrate what each tool can produce when used by somebody who may not have advanced prompting, coding or web design experience. First, I create separate Brilliant Directories widgets for BD Butler, ChatGPT and Claude. I then generate a pricing page with each AI, add the resulting code to Brilliant Directories and compare the designs directly on the website. BD Butler produces a surprisingly polished result on the first attempt, including attractive pricing cards, a comparison table, strong contrast and a call-to-action section. I also test the page on mobile to see how the pricing plans and comparison table behave on smaller screens. Next, we look at ChatGPT. The page has some good elements, but it also adds navigation links that weren't requested and has areas where the font contrast and comparison table could be improved. Finally, we test Claude. Claude is capable of producing very high-quality website designs when given detailed instructions, but with this simple prompt the result needs significantly more refinement. For this particular experiment, BD Butler comes out on top. One of BD Butler's biggest advantages is that it works directly inside Brilliant Directories and understands elements of your existing website design and branding. The comparison also demonstrates an important point about AI website design: better prompts and more detailed instructions can dramatically improve the results. BD Butler, ChatGPT and Claude can all be powerful tools, but the best option can depend on your experience, the quality of your prompt and how much customisation you want to do afterwards. ⏱️ VIDEO CHAPTERS 00:00 Introduction 00:13 BD Butler, ChatGPT and Claude comparison 00:38 The pricing page challenge 00:54 Creating the three Brilliant Directories widgets 01:35 Starting with BD Butler 01:48 Using widgets vs the text editor 03:09 Creating the pricing page prompt 04:11 Pricing tiers and responsive comparison table 05:16 Sending the same prompt to all three AIs 06:05 Reviewing the BD Butler result 06:40 Adding the BD Butler widget to the page 06:54 BD Butler pricing page review 08:05 Testing BD Butler on mobile 08:51 Moving to ChatGPT 09:24 Reviewing the ChatGPT preview 09:42 Adding ChatGPT code to Brilliant Directories 10:20 Reviewing the ChatGPT pricing page 11:03 BD Butler vs ChatGPT 11:40 Testing ChatGPT on mobile 12:18 Moving to Claude 12:39 Adding the Claude code 13:14 Reviewing the Claude pricing page 14:42 Choosing the winner 15:19 Why BD Butler works well with simple prompts 15:46 BD Butler branding and design settings 16:06 Final comparison 16:35 The winner 16:52 Final thoughts 💻 NEED BRILLIANT DIRECTORIES HELP? I offer one-to-one Brilliant Directories website build, customisation, redesign and support services: https://www.membershipwebsites.net Contact me for help with BD Butler, AI website design, pricing pages, custom widgets, membership plans or advanced Brilliant Directories development. 🚀 START A 7-DAY FREE TRIAL OF BRILLIANT DIRECTORIES Start your free trial here — no card needed: https://directory.brilliantdirectorie... 👥 JOIN OUR BRILLIANT DIRECTORIES FACEBOOK GROUP   / 1738565746879172   👍 FOUND THIS VIDEO HELPFUL? Please like the video, subscribe for more Brilliant Directories tutorials, and leave a comment telling me which result you preferred — BD Butler, ChatGPT or Claude. #BrilliantDirectories #BDButler #ChatGPT #ClaudeAI #BrilliantDirectoriesTutorial #DirectoryWebsite #MembershipWebsite #AIWebsiteBuilder #WebsiteDesign