Why Would Anyone Build Here?
NATMYST
0:00 / 0:00
Why Would Anyone Build Here?
101 просмотр · 2 нед. назад
NATMYST
7 подписчиков
101 просмотр · 2 нед. назад
A monastery on a stone pillar. A village pressed into a cliff. A temple carved out of one hillside. They look impossible, and most of them aren't: we know how people built them. What we don't know is who, when, or why. Five real places, real sources, and an honest word where scientists disagree.
#ImpossiblePlaces #Archaeology #AncientMysteries
TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Why would anyone build here?
0:55 Impossible Places #1
1:11 #1 Meteora, Greece: how did they get up there?
3:48 #2 Cliff Palace, USA: why did they leave?
5:56 #3 Kailasa, India: who carved it?
8:10 #4 Lalibela, Ethiopia: two stories, one place
10:18 #5 Göbekli Tepe, Turkey: why, before there was anything?
12:45 Which one would you want to see first?
SOURCES (what the story is based on)
1. Meteora: UNESCO World Heritage listing; the Varlaam katholikon (1541/42 inscription; founders Nektarios and Theophanes Apsaras of Ioannina); monastery sources on access by ladders, nets and baskets; steps cut in the 1920s.
2. Mesa Verde: US National Park Service (Cliff Palace; tree-ring dating, last tree-ring date 1281; Petroglyph Point interpretation by a Hopi elder; affiliated Pueblo peoples). Kohler, Kemp et al., 2017, PLoS ONE: ancient turkey DNA and the migration out of Mesa Verde (an inference, see the video).
3. Kailasa / Ellora: Goetz 1952; Dhavalikar 1982; Epigraphia Indica (Vadodara copper plate, c. 812 CE; Cave 15 inscription of Dantidurga, Saka 675 / c. 753 CE, sources differ on legibility).
4. Lalibela: Derat, Bosc-Tiessé et al., 2021, Antiquity ("The rock-cut churches of Lalibela and the cave church of Washa Mika'el"); CNRS news on the Lalibela Mission excavations (since 2008); David Phillipson's earlier dating (Aksumite period).
5. Göbekli Tepe: German Archaeological Institute (DAI) excavation reports and "Tepe Telegrams"; Klaus Schmidt; UNESCO World Heritage listing.
Dates and numbers marked "about" in the video are estimates from the literature and vary between sources.
HOW THIS VIDEO WAS MADE
Researched, selected and checked by the NATMYST team. Every claim is tied to the sources above; where sources disagree, we say so. Narration is AI-generated (ElevenLabs) from our own script. Photos are free-licensed and credited.
CREDITS (photos from Wikimedia Commons, CC BY / CC BY-SA / public domain; full list on request)
Meteora: Berthold Werner, Giles Laurent, Gidvgreece, Long lasting memories, AngelikiC, Joyofmuseums, Misa.stefanovic.07, Stathis Floros, Mrcsifkin, Nicholas Catsimpoolas, ArsenG, rob Stoeltje, Jolovema, Vipers10687, Sadopaul, Dimitra Papadimitriou. 1923 film "Moni Varlaam" (extract): Michael Dorizas (public domain).
Mesa Verde: NealVickers, Lacee Curtis, William Henry Jackson, C. C. Pierce, Fay C. Cole, John Fowler, Sandra Bellouguet, Doss Imaging, G. Lamar, Lisafern, G. Edward Johnson, runt35, Tobi 87, Michael Barera, Will Thomas, Lance Johnson, mark byzewski, Jeffrey Beall, Mattivxx, KimonBerlin, John Manard, James St. John, NPS.
Kailasa / Ellora: Prasant1995, Gandla naveen, Saniyunus, Rohit Sharma, Anjan Kumar Kundu, Shishirdasika, Shreyans69, Bhajish Bharathan, Arian Zwegers, Ballabh Yadav, Sankarshanmukhopadhyay, Sailko, Vaibhav.n.shinde, Aums90, Akshay Prakash, Tanya98766, Dey.sandip, Anshuman.borah, Sharatravan.
Lalibela: Hervé Doulat, Sailko, Rod Waddington, A. Davey, Chuck Moravec, Thomas Fuhrmann.
Göbekli Tepe: Dosseman, Immanuelle, Hamdigumus, Marco Restano, Kerimbesler, Teomancimit, Radosław Botev, Spica-Vega Photo Arts (Banu Nazikcan), Philrock, Klaus-Peter Simon.
Maps: Imagery © Esri, Maxar, Earthstar Geographics.
Sound: griffon vulture recording by Thomas Signeau, CC BY-SA 4.0, xeno-canto XC917400 (Wikimedia Commons). Ambient wind recordings from Wikimedia Commons (see earlier NATMYST videos for the licences). Music: Mixkit. Sound effects partly generated. Voice: AI narration (ElevenLabs).
Welcome to NATMYST: real places, real science, no myths and no clickbait. Subscribe if you want more Impossible Places, two new videos every week.