David Phelps and Guy Penrod Reunite to Sing Together — What Bill Gaither Said Left Both in Tears

David Phelps and Guy Penrod Reunite to Sing Together — What Bill Gaither Said Left Both in Tears They haven't recorded together since they were both in the Gaither Vocal Band. Guy Penrod left in 2009. David Phelps left in 2017. For seventeen years, fans have been asking one question — when will we hear those two voices together again? That day came this year. Penrod and Phelps stood in front of the same microphone and sang "It Is Well with My Soul" for the upcoming tribute album "You Are Loved: A Tribute to the Songs of Bill and Gloria Gaither," releasing September 25, 2026. Bill Gaither was in the room. He was ninety years old, sitting quietly in a chair in the corner. And when they finished singing, he said two words that broke everyone in the room — including the two men standing at the microphone. This video tells the full story — how Penrod and Phelps each found their way to the Gaither Vocal Band, what that combination sounded like during the golden years from 1997 to 2005, what happened when each of them left, and what it meant when they finally came back together on one of the most beloved hymns in the history of the church. If you grew up on Gaither Homecoming videos, if you wore out the tapes, if you played those DVDs on Sunday afternoons and nobody in your house complained — this one is for you. The story behind those two words Bill Gaither said starts at 9:00. 📀 Album: "You Are Loved: A Tribute to the Songs of Bill and Gloria Gaither" 📅 Release Date: September 25, 2026 🎤 Featured Track: David Phelps & Guy Penrod — "It Is Well with My Soul" #DavidPhelps #GuyPenrod #BillGaither #GaitherVocalBand #ItIsWellWithMySoul