What Did Crying Pastor's Jury Think About His Mistress?

Caleb Flynn was found guilty of murdering his wife, Ashley Flynn, then staging her death to look like a deadly home invasion. The former American Idol contestant and pastor broke down in tears nearly every day of the trial, but his emotional displays weren't enough to convince the jury. On this episode, Matt Johnson sits down with 'East Idaho News' News Director Nate Eaton, who spoke with one of the jurors, to reveal what was happening behind closed courthouse doors, and what ultimately led to the guilty verdict. Subscribe to Justice with Matt Johnson for true crime analysis, breaking legal developments, and case updates: https://bit.ly/JusticeOnYouTube Follow Justice with Matt Johnson on Facebook:   / justicewithmattjohnson   Follow Matt Johnson on X: https://x.com/MattJohnsonNEWS Follow Matt Johnon on Facebook:   / mattjohnsonnews   #TrueCrime #Justice #CalebFlynn #CalebFlynnTrial #MattJohnson