MANIFEST vs KATSEYE | IT WASN'T EVEN CLOSE!

MANIFEST vs KATSEYE, measured: their debut songs and their three biggest music videos, head to head over seven rounds, with a scoreboard at the end. ⏎ One group came out of HYBE and Geffen's Dream Academy. The other came out of a YouTube talent show. So which one is actually better? 👇 Who wins your head-to-head? Put your winner, and your bias, in the comments. ▶ The full story of MANIFEST's last five music videos:    • Reaction To manifest - Amatör, Başrol Sens...   CHAPTERS 0:00 MANIFEST vs KATSEYE: the setup 0:37 Dream Academy vs Big5 Türkiye + how I measured 1:20 Round 1: Debut vs Zamansızdık 4:00 Round 2: Touch vs Hileli (feat. Ajda Pekkan) 6:57 Round 3: Gnarly vs Toz Pembe 9:50 Round 4: Gameboy vs Amatör 11:51 The members: every voice + my bias picks 13:05 Round 5: the lyrics 13:46 Round 6: reach (views, likes, charts) 14:08 Round 7: connection (comments, tickets) 14:53 Final score and verdict KATSEYE: Debut, Touch, Gnarly, Gameboy. MANIFEST: Zamansızdık, Hileli (with Ajda Pekkan), Toz Pembe, Amatör. Reaction to every song and break down the lyrics, the music videos, the styling, the sets, the lighting and the choreography, with real measurements: pitch accuracy, held notes, vocal range, how loud the vocals sit in the mix, the biggest energy jumps, editing on the beat, repeated lines, views, likes, comments, charts and ticket sales. Plus every member's voice, measured on her own solo recording, and my bias in each group. More K-pop and music analysis on Laurent:    / @sl7official   THE EIGHT VIDEOS KATSEYE, Debut:    • KATSEYE (캣츠아이) "Debut" Official MV   KATSEYE, Touch:    • KATSEYE (캣츠아이) "Touch" Official MV   KATSEYE, Gnarly:    • KATSEYE (캣츠아이) "Gnarly" Official MV   KATSEYE, Gameboy:    • KATSEYE (캣츠아이) "Gameboy” Official MV   MANIFEST, Zamansızdık (dance video):    • manifest - Zamansızdık | Official Dance Video   MANIFEST x Ajda Pekkan, Hileli:    • manifest X Ajda Pekkan - Hileli | Official...   MANIFEST, Toz Pembe:    • manifest - Toz Pembe | Official Music Video   MANIFEST, Amatör:    • manifest - Amatör | Official Music Video   FAIR USE This is a critical analysis and commentary. Short excerpts of the official videos appear, some with their audio, alongside official artwork, for criticism, comparison and analysis under fair use (17 U.S.C. § 107). No lyrics are shown or quoted. All rights belong to their owners; please watch the originals. #MANIFEST #KATSEYE #kpop #MANIFESTvsKATSEYE #TurkishPop #tralala