I Ranked Every New Anime of Fall 2026

Fall 2026 while not as stacked as Summer gives us both a solid season of entries and some breathing room to catch up with older titles. But, with over 30 new shows airing, I sat down and watched every single premiere so you don't have to. In this massive tier list, I’m ranking the entire Fall 2026 season from D-Tier to S-Tier based on their first episodes. For every series covered, I give you a quick summary of the premise wrapped up within a larger discussion of why I like it or don't. Whether you're curious if The Apothecary Diaries Season 3 holds up (It does), looking for hidden gems (There are several), or wondering why I have a reincarnation isekai as an absolute masterpiece, this is your guide on what to watch (and what to skip) this season. 🕒 Navigate the Rankings: 00:00 - Intro & The Rules (Tier Division!) 02:27 - D-Tier (The Meh) 05:02 - C-Tier (The "Just Fine") 08:33 - B-Tier (Your Mileage May Vary) 20:45 - A-Tier (The Must-Watch Contenders) 29:54 - S-Tier (My Absolute Best) 32:42 - Final Thoughts & Outro 🎧 Want more in-depth anime discussions? Make sure to follow and listen to my podcast QUEST FOR THE BEST! Also with Geoff ( ⁨@mothersbasement⁩ ) and Miles (Industry Professional) ►On Youtube:    / @questforthebestpod   ► On Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/6k0rRm2... Support the channel: ►Patreon:   / arkada   ►Where to stream these shows legally from our friends at Yatta Tachi: https://yattatachi.com/watch-Summer-2...