Bir Tawil: The Land Nobody Wants
Maps That Make No Sense
0:00 / 0:00
Bir Tawil: The Land Nobody Wants
338 просмотров · 2 нед. назад
Maps That Make No Sense
14 подписчиков
338 просмотров · 2 нед. назад
Bir Tawil is a 2,060 square kilometre patch of desert between Egypt and Sudan that no country claims. This video explains why Egypt and Sudan both refuse it, how two British boundary lines from 1899 and 1902 created the gap, who tried to claim it with a flag, and what the law says.
Chapters
00:00 Intro
00:40 The Place
01:36 Two Lines
02:39 The Trap
03:54 The Prize
04:53 The Other Leftover
05:42 The King
06:54 The Second King
07:35 Why a Flag Is Not Enough
08:34 Another Nobody's Land
09:05 The Answer
09:51 Outro
Notes on accuracy
Area and geography follow Wikipedia (Bir Tawil, Halaib Triangle, Wadi Halfa Salient). The Hala'ib figure of 20,580 km² is the one given by Wikipedia.
The 1899 and 1902 lines and each country's position are described neutrally; the dispute is unresolved.
The claims by Jeremiah Heaton (2014) and Suyash Dixit (2017) were never recognised by any government.
Maps use Natural Earth and OpenStreetMap boundary data; the Hala'ib outline is approximate.
The narration uses a synthetic voice cloned from the channel owner's own voice.
Sources
Wikipedia: Bir Tawil; Halaib Triangle; Egypt–Sudan border; Wadi Halfa Salient; Marie Byrd Land
UN Digital Library: letter from Sudan to the Security Council, 16 March 2016
TIME, The Columbian, Al Jazeera on Jeremiah Heaton; Fox News, YourStory on Suyash Dixit
Montevideo Convention on the Rights and Duties of States (1933)
Credits
Photos (Wikimedia Commons): Aerra Carnicom (CC BY-SA 4.0), Vyacheslav Argenberg (CC BY 4.0), Gerhard Haubold (CC BY-SA 3.0), Thomon (CC BY-SA 4.0), Marc Ryckaert (CC BY 3.0), Klaus Polak (CC BY-SA 3.0), Hatem Moushir (CC BY-SA 4.0), Mohamed Shokry Algarnosy (CC BY-SA 4.0), Przemyslaw Idzkiewicz (CC BY-SA 2.0), Richard Buchta, Harris & Ewing, Maximilian Dörrbecker, NASA Johnson Space Center, NASA/Michael Studinger (public domain). Video clips: Pixabay (Pixabay Content License). Map data: OpenStreetMap contributors (ODbL), Natural Earth.
#borders #geography #maps