Comparing Ardbeg Trudernish and Uigeadail

For years, Ardbeg Uigeadail has been my favourite bottle from the Ardbeg core range. Not because it wins on a spreadsheet, but because it gives me exactly what I look for in an Ardbeg: smoke, dark fruit, sweetness and enough rough edges to keep things interesting. Then Trudernish 15 Years Old arrived. And suddenly there was a question that needed answering. Can it replace Uigeadail?