What if Ada Shelby had stayed with the communists?
PeakyTheories
0:00 / 0:00
What if Ada Shelby had stayed with the communists?
82 просмотра · 1 месяц назад
PeakyTheories
44 подписчика
82 просмотра · 1 месяц назад
Ada Shelby is born in Birmingham around 1897, the only girl in a house of gangsters, and she reads. Not the cleverest of the Shelbys — Tommy holds that — but the one who asks whether the thing is worth having. She marries Freddie Thorne, a shop steward on a police list and Tommy's oldest friend from before the war, and they name their son Karl.
Freddie dies of typhoid in 1922. In the series, that is where Ada begins drifting back: London first, then money, then work for the Shelby Company, then a directorship by the thirties. Her politics are never argued out of her. They are diluted.
The divergence here is not a decision. It is a job. In the autumn of 1922 the National Union of Distributive and Allied Workers offers her clerical work as a women's organiser's assistant, thirty-two shillings a week. She takes it.
Thirty-two shillings is slightly less than a Birmingham labourer earns. Nine shillings goes on two rooms in Sparkbrook, three or four on winter coal, fourteen on food for two if she is careful. That leaves about five shillings for boots, doctors, gas, and everything that goes wrong — while her brother is buying a country house.
The thesis is that conviction is not a set of opinions but arithmetic somebody has decided to keep doing. Arthur turns up with money roughly once a month for two years and she sends him away every time, because taking it means saying yes the next time the family wants something. Tommy never offers directly. He offers through Polly, and she refuses through Polly, so neither of them ever has that conversation.
What she turns out to be good at is unglamorous. Lists, rotas, getting eleven people who dislike each other into a room and out with a decision. Between 1923 and 1926 she organises Birmingham's shop workers — young women on eleven shillings for sixty-hour weeks, scattered across two thousand small premises — in the half-hour before opening, four mornings a week, for three years. The district goes from about eighty members to just over nine hundred.
Then May 1926, the General Strike, nine days, Birmingham at the centre of it, and a night on the picket line where the person on the other side is her own brother.
Thirty years later a woman of fifty stands up in the House of Commons and describes a street without ever saying whose street it was.
💡 On that night in 1926, with the picket line on one side and her brother on the other, what do you think Ada should have done? Tell me in the comments.
🎵 Musik (CC BY): "Dark | Dark Cinematic Electronic Music | CC BY 4.0 | by Muted Symphony" by Muted Symphony (CC-BY, • Dark | Dark Cinematic Electronic Music | C... )
If the story held you, leave a sub — there's a new one every week.
Storytelling method inspired by Three Eyed Theorist – / @threeeyedtheorist
Kapitel:
00:00 Intro
00:44 Who Ada actually is
01:49 What the series does with her afterwards
02:35 The change
03:27 What thirty-two shillings actually was
04:39 What it costs immediately
05:48 What she becomes
06:56 The women nobody organised
08:42 The General Strike
11:26 What the strike does
12:24 What Freddie left her
14:07 Leaving the Party
15:20 What the family thinks
16:17 The thirties
17:50 The candidate she couldn't be
19:24 The story he kills
20:54 Mosley
23:04 Polly
24:28 The war
25:28 Nineteen forty-five
26:35 The speech
28:42 The first year in the House
30:27 What she does with eleven years
31:34 The Health Service
33:14 Karl
34:48 The house she gets built
36:06 What Tommy makes of it
37:03 What the family loses
38:00 How it ends
39:02 The last twenty years
40:41 The one thing she never resolves
41:52 What this says about the story
43:57 What she'd have been in the family
45:04 What this says about you
47:35 What it costs to be that person
48:33 What's left
50:06 One last thing