Which Version Of Half-Life Blue Shift Is More Immersive?

Also let me know which one you find more immersive, or don't. (please do) Really sick timestamps 00:00 Intro 00:46 The Incredible Atmosphere Of Blue Shift's Opening 02:10 Immersion Vs Realism 03:42 The Horror Of Blue Shift 04:43 Solving Puzzles Through Interactions 05:48 The Small Details In Blue Shift 06:49 The Subtle Storytelling of Blue Shift 09:08 Do Realistic Graphics Matter? 10:35 The Worst Looking Part Of The Remake 12:47 The Reason We All Like Half-Life